We Don’t Need No Stinking Zealous Advocacy

Attorney Marc J. Victor

Back in the good old days when Americans were interested in freedom, criminal defense attorneys had an ethical duty to zealously advocate for their clients. The concept being that an adversarial system of justice was more likely to produce just results than an inquisitorial system of justice. However, the Arizona Supreme Court recently decided that the age-old duty of zealous advocacy is no longer appropriate. Attorneys in Arizona now have no such ethical duty.

I interpret this change to mean the government has determined it is no longer in the government’s interest for criminal defense attorneys to be zealous when they fight the government. No kidding. One could expect nothing different so long as the government supplies all the judges, the prosecutors and strictly regulates all criminal defense attorneys. Imagine a situation where one baseball team unilaterally approves and pays the umpires and determines who plays for the other team. You wouldn’t be shocked when they picked players for the other team who agreed not to play too zealously.

I recently tried a case for a client who was charged with a crime arising out of a barroom brawl. I suspected the arresting police officer wouldn’t be able to identify my client at the trial but would nonetheless testify under oath that he could. On the day of trial, I asked my client to sit in the back row of the courtroom while his uninvolved friend accompanied me at the defense table. I informed the court my client was present in the courtroom and we were ready for trial.

As expected, the officer testified under oath that the friend sitting next to me was the man he arrested. He was absolutely certain. I immediately informed the court that I did not agree the officer had identified my client. After the government rested its case, the friend testified revealing his identity. After some expected legal wrangling, the judge entered a judgment of acquittal. My client was thrilled. The aggravated prosecutor stormed out of the courtroom.

Months later, I learned the prosecutor’s supervisor filed a bar complaint against me alleging I misled the court and an investigation was commencing. My state-granted privilege to enter into voluntary contracts with adults for representation was at stake. To his credit, the elected judge backed me and signed an affidavit stating I did nothing to mislead him. This did not deter the bar or the prosecutor who was determined to punish me for misleading the judge who says he was not misled. Indeed, the prosecutor argued to the bar that the judge’s opinion about not being misled was not relevant. After months of haggling, the state bar grudgingly admitted I had not violated any ethical duties and the complaint against me was dismissed.

Despite the fact that we all know what happened that day in court, no complaint was ever filed against the government police officer. No government investigation was commenced against the government police officer. None was expected. Government courts have ruled that government police officers are permitted to lie to citizens all they want. They often do. However, government prosecutors often charge citizens with crimes if a citizen lies to a government police officer.

So long as the government administers the criminal justice system, only the government will be protected. Whenever you find yourself in a government court fighting the government, remember that the government doesn’t want your attorney to have an ethical obligation to zealously represent you. They want your quick plea of guilty and the accompanying fines and various sanctions which now include your DNA in many cases. Although it may seem unfair, I’m sure the government set up this system with only our protection in mind.

Attorney Marc J. Victor

Eye On P.
Eye On P.
1720977655
I signed up for an account on a Sunday and made an error. I was completely surprised when Shanice... contacted me via email to help fix the error. That was incredible as I was going to wait until Monday to call and get help. Very proactive and professional. If this is an indication as to the type of service they provide, I made the right choice.read more
Dana M.
Dana M.
1720909366
I spoke with Miss Shanice on a Saturday. She returned my call within a couple of hours. She was... very pleasant and professional. We converted my plan to the Family Plan. It took less than five minutes. I'm very pleased with AOR. I hope that I'll never need them.read more
J R
J R
1720655144
The Attorney and Paralegal I worked with did an extraordinary job in aiding my comprehension of the... legal system as it pertained to my situation. Attorney Emma Wittmann and Paralegal Tory Stewart were both extreme knowledgeable, efficient at answering any/all questions, and went above and beyond in all aspects. I am quite pleased with their work. I absolutely and unequivocally recommend both Attorney Emma Wittmann and Paralegal Tory Stewart should you be in need of legal counsel, and by extension law firm Attorneys for Freedom. Thank you all so much!read more
Timothy M.
Timothy M.
1720647678
I researched Attorneys On Retainer extensively and found nothing but excellent reviews. I want to... add my review of five stars to the reviews after interacting with the firm and specifically Mike Wasdin. He was a great help in navigating the paperwork and my membership within the organization. Thank You Mike.read more
gilbert C.
gilbert C.
1720060140
This message is for all the gun owners in the state of Connecticut recently we have some new laws... which are very ridiculous but anyway this is regarding the Attorneys For Freedom the return every cent that I spend for the past year because they couldn’t work in the state of Connecticut, but they have the integrity and the ethics to still represent us in case of self-defense cases without charging usthey’re working to see if they can change the law and be able to work one more time in the state of Connecticut I would like to encourage every gun owner in the state of Connecticut and outside the state of Connecticut that happen to have the same situation that we and write a review a positive review because they deserve itI have to admit I was very surprised, but it was a good surprise. It is rare to find this caliber of people.They are willing to do the right thing so please support Attorneys For Freedom because they are unique among the rest.read more
js_loader